Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bryce Tolpen's avatar

You go deeply into the mixed messages we often send through our perennial plea of "Hosanna." The ambivalence of its message--captured in the rock opera of my youth as "Hey JC, JC, won't you fight for me? / Sanna ho, Sanna hey, Superstar"--seems inconsistent with our calling as the "body of Messiah," Paul's "filling up" of Messiah's sufferings as they would apply here and now.

I learned a lot here about Tutu's approach to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. I love your expression "the easy authority of applause," which sounds like something from a Martin Luther King speech. I also loved this observation--both its substance and expression: "Amnesty was given for full honesty, not as an excuse but as a risk for a shared future." Your chosen example here of forgiveness as a means of moving forward connects so nicely with where Palm Sunday's hosannahs and Good Friday's "Father, forgive them"--taken together--point. As you remind me, the Passion narrative beginning with Jesus riding into Jerusalem holds "praise and crucifixion together in a single liturgy."

William C. Green's avatar

Thanks for your generous response, Bryce! Very encouraging.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?